Search results

Advanced search   My selection

Does apprenticeship still have meaning in the UK?: the consequences of voluntarism and sectoral change

This chapter provides an overview of the development of apprenticeships in the UK, exploring the extent to which contemporary apprenticeships resemble their historical predecessors and whether they have relevance for young people and employers today. The chapter is presented in four sections: the first section gives a historical overview of apprenticeships in the UK; the second section shows how the current system differs from the past in terms of apprentice characteristics and the sectors in which apprenticeships are available; in section three, some of the issues and problems emerging from the Mature Apprenticeship (MA) program are identified and case studies from the engineering and banking sectors are used to show the types of provision that currently count as apprenticeship; and the final section highlights a number of challenges for policy makers and concludes that the flexible and weakly regulated model of apprenticeship that has emerged in the UK has resulted in great variations in the quality of provision.

This chapter provides an overview of the development of apprenticeships in the UK, exploring the extent to which ...  Show Full Abstract  

Authors: Fuller, Alison; Unwin, Lorna
Date: 2004
Geographic subjects: Europe; Great Britain
Resource type: Book chapter
Subjects: Apprenticeship; Participation; Research;

VITAL Object

Fit for purpose?: sixty years of VET policy in England

This chapter, which is presented in six sections, provides an assessment of the aims and content of vocational education and training (VET) policy in England since 1945. The first section covers the 30-35 years after 1945, a period in which 'initial attempts to deliver policy aims by legislating for individual and employer participation were first diluted and then abandoned'; the second section looks at the period when the government entered into specific contracts with VET providers for course delivery, thereby exerting some influence; section three covers the era of assessment, qualifications and institutional reform; section four provides an overview of the last 60 years; in section five, a number of assumptions on which recent policies appear to be based are identified; and the final section examines some recent developments. The chapter concludes with a set of key lessons learnt from the review of the last 60 years. They include: England still does not have a coherent VET policy and is in need of one; attractive and flexible vocational learning programs are needed, as well as rigorous and relevant vocational qualifications; and there is a need to establish and maintain a properly resourced VET infrastructure.

This chapter, which is presented in six sections, provides an assessment of the aims and content of vocational education and ...  Show Full Abstract  

Authors: Stanton, Geoff; Bailey, Bill
Date: 2004
Geographic subjects: Europe; Great Britain; England
Resource type: Book chapter
Subjects: Vocational education and training; Assessment; Qualifications;

VITAL Object

Becoming a chef: the politics and culture of learning

This final chapter looks at the central theme of the monograph: the desire on the part of policy makers to reform their nation's education and training systems. It reflects on the conflict between the politics and the established culture of learning within which key terms such as competence and outcomes take on different meanings. A UK case study of the learning of apprentice chefs is used to illustrate this conflict. The development of the competence-based approach to skill certification via the National Vocational Qualifications (NVQs) is explored. The authors argue that this approach 'has been largely ineffectual in making headway against a culture of learning that is long established, favours an alternative conception to that promoted with the NVQ, and places great value on a particular process of learning'.

This final chapter looks at the central theme of the monograph: the desire on the part of policy makers to reform their ...  Show Full Abstract  

Authors: James, Susan; Hayward, Geoff
Date: 2004
Geographic subjects: Europe; Great Britain
Resource type: Book chapter
Subjects: Assessment; Apprenticeship; Teaching and learning;

VITAL Object

Producing skills: conundrums and possibilities

In recent years, the key strategy employed by governments worldwide to improve national competitiveness has been to develop the skills of the workforce. This introductory chapter looks at the central theme of the book: the desire on the part of policy makers to reform the education and training systems to align them more closely with the perceived needs of the labour market. The increasing focus on the supply side of the skills equation while ignoring the demand side results in neglecting other issues such as 'competitive strategies, labour market regulation, work organisation, job design, and the quality of working life'.

In recent years, the key strategy employed by governments worldwide to improve national competitiveness has been to develop ...  Show Full Abstract  

Authors: Hayward, Geoff; James, Susan
Date: 2004
Geographic subjects: North America; Europe; Great Britain;
Resource type: Book chapter
Subjects: Vocational education and training; Labour market; Skills and knowledge;

VITAL Object

'I can't believe it's not skill': the changing meaning of skill in the UK context and some implications

This chapter explores the broadening definition of the term 'skill' over the last 20 years and its implications for vocational education and training (VET) policy and practice in the UK. The main changes that have occurred in the official conceptualisation of skill in the UK and the driving forces behind this process are outlined in the first section of the chapter. The second section highlights two broad implications of the changing definition of skill. The first relates to the reinforcement of middle-class advantage in the labour market, and the second points to the danger of defining skill so widely that 'the notion of what it means to be skilled, en-skilled or up-skilled becomes progressively diluted and meaningless'. It also highlights two implications for the education system: firstly, the broadening definition of skill makes the tasks of those responsible for managing the VET system in the UK much more problematic; and secondly, the shift it causes in the balance of responsibility between employers and the education system in the provision of initial VET. The chapter argues that the key place for skill development is the workplace and that there is an urgent need for a public debate on the role of employers and the education system in skill development.

This chapter explores the broadening definition of the term 'skill' over the last 20 years and its implications for ...  Show Full Abstract  

Authors: Keep, Ewart; Payne, Jonathan
Date: 2004
Geographic subjects: Europe; Great Britain
Resource type: Book chapter
Subjects: Vocational education and training; Skills and knowledge; Workforce development;

VITAL Object

Interests, arguments and ideologies: employers' involvement in education-business partnerships in the US and the UK

This chapter, which is based on literature, interview and observational data gathered in secondary schools in the US and UK during 1997-98, examines the 'added value' of education-business partnerships. The education systems of the US and UK are compared, showing that both systems share some similarities in terms of challenges to prepare students for the world of work and the use of education-business partnerships to achieve this objective. The themes of isolationism and exploitation are examined from the educator's perspective and graduation and jobs from the student's perspective. The education and training agenda from an employer's perspective is also explored. The chapter concludes that while partnerships are perceived as inherently good for the future and benefits include work experience, equipment donation, mentoring and professional development, there is also uncertainty about the purpose and form of such partnerships. The issue of the shifting burden of paying for education and training from state to business is raised.

This chapter, which is based on literature, interview and observational data gathered in secondary schools in the US and UK ...  Show Full Abstract  

Authors: Greenwald, Suzanne
Date: 2004
Geographic subjects: North America; Europe; Great Britain;
Resource type: Book chapter
Subjects: Skills and knowledge; Finance; Research;

VITAL Object

Tradition and reform: modernising the German dual system of vocational education

The focus of this chapter is on the dual system of apprenticeship in Germany. It argues that the broad consensus among the relevant stakeholders on the underlying principles of the dual system is the main reason for its prolonged success. However, there are signs that the dual system is at risk and the need to modernise it and make it more flexible is widely acknowledged among researchers and educators. The chapter begins by outlining the current debate on the dual system. The advantages of the system are then outlined against the background of its underlying principles. Examples of reform initiatives are included and the reasons for their limited success are explained. Finally, the concept of 'areas of learning' is discussed. This concept is seen as being more promising in achieving reform as it initiates the modernisation processes at a number of levels while acknowledging the underlying principles of duality.

The focus of this chapter is on the dual system of apprenticeship in Germany. It argues that the broad consensus among the ...  Show Full Abstract  

Authors: Ertl, Hubert
Date: 2004
Geographic subjects: Europe; Germany
Resource type: Book chapter
Subjects: Vocational education and training; Apprenticeship; Governance

VITAL Object

Compatible higher education systems and the European labour market: Bologna and beyond

The Bologna Declaration was signed in 1999 by 30 European countries committed to the creation of a 'European area of higher education' (HE) that was announced in the Sorbonne Declaration a year earlier. Its aim is to enhance the cohesion and compatibility of HE systems within Europe and their attractiveness throughout the world. This chapter examines the reform of the European HE system through the Bologna Process and the key role of employability in the European labour market in the Bologna Process. Driving these reforms is the same employability and skills agenda that underpins the reform of the vocational education and training (VET) system. The report concludes that the recent review of the Bologna Process undertaken in Berlin in 2003 indicates that 'the Bologna agenda for convergent structural reforms has every reason to continue all over Europe'.

The Bologna Declaration was signed in 1999 by 30 European countries committed to the creation of a 'European area of higher ...  Show Full Abstract  

Authors: Haug, Guy
Date: 2004
Geographic subjects: Europe
Resource type: Book chapter
Subjects: Higher education; Labour market; Skills and knowledge;

VITAL Object

The expansion of higher education: economic necessity or hyperinflation?

Concerns about the expansion of education, especially in relation to the evaluation of its socioeconomic benefits and costs, attracted much attention and debate in the second half of the 20th century. This chapter outlines the history of the expansion of higher education (HE). It distinguishes between the different modalities of expansion and considers the expansion of HE as an economic necessity as well as the sociological perspective. The chapter concludes that the expansion of HE in its traditional form appears to be: a socio-political necessity in terms of input, i.e. who gets access; an economic necessity in terms of process, i.e. local job creation, demographic vitality and export; and a qualitative question mark in terms of output. It lays 'bare the fact that what has been at stake in gaining a university experience are the social benefits that such an experience is expected to confer'.

Concerns about the expansion of education, especially in relation to the evaluation of its socioeconomic benefits and costs, ...  Show Full Abstract  

Authors: Deer, Cecile
Date: 2004
Geographic subjects: Europe
Resource type: Book chapter
Subjects: Providers of education and training; Higher education; Economics;

VITAL Object

Balancing the skills equation: key policy issues and challenges for policy and practice

In recent years, governments worldwide have focused on developing the skills of the workforce as the key strategy to improving national competitiveness. This book, which is based on work undertaken by the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) Research Centre on Skills, Knowledge and Organisational Performance (SKOPE), examines this high skills agenda at both policy and practice levels. The theme of the book is the desire on the part of policy makers to align the education and training systems more closely with the perceived needs of the labour market by reforming their countries' education and training systems. The chapters are: Producing skills: conundrums and possibilities / Geoff Hayward and Susan James; Fit for purpose?: sixty years of VET policy in England / Geoff Stanton and Bill Bailey; The European policy regarding education and training: a critical assessment / Jean-Luc De Meulemeester and Denis Rochat; 'I can't believe it's not skill': the changing meaning of skill in the UK context and some implications / Ewart Keep and Jonathan Payne; Qualifying for a job: an educational and economic audit of the English 14-19 education and training system / Rosa M. Fernandez and Geoff Hayward; Does apprenticeship still have meaning in the UK?: the consequences of voluntarism and sectoral change / Alison Fuller and Lorna Unwin; Tradition and reform: modernising the German dual system of vocational education / Hubert Ertl; Learning in the workplace: reappraisals and reconceptions / Stephen Billett; Interests, arguments and ideologies: employers' involvement in education-business partnerships in the US and the UK / Suzanne Greenwald; Compatible higher education systems and the European labour market: Bologna and beyond / Guy Haug; The expansion of higher education: economic necessity or hyperinflation? / Cecile Deer; Becoming a chef: the politics and culture of learning / Susan James and Geoff Hayward.

In recent years, governments worldwide have focused on developing the skills of the workforce as the key strategy to ...  Show Full Abstract  

Authors: Hayward, Geoff; James, Susan
Date: 2004
Geographic subjects: North America; Europe; Germany;
Resource type: Book
Subjects: Vocational education and training; Apprenticeship; Higher education;

VITAL Object