Does it really matter where you study?

Printer-friendly versionPrinter-friendly version

Permanent URL for this page: http://hdl.voced.edu.au/10707/148233.


Author: Smyth, Roger; Hyatt, Jamie; Nair, Bhaskaran; Smart, Warren

Corporate author:
New Zealand. Ministry of Education. Tertiary Sector Performance Analysis and Reporting

Abstract:

This report compares the earnings of people who have completed a bachelors degree at a university with the earnings those who completed a similar qualification at a polytechnic. The key finding of the report is that there is no evidence to substantiate claims of labour market discrimination against polytechnic degrees. In particular: there is no discrimination at the point of entry into the labour market - the median earnings of those entering the workforce with a bachelors degree from a polytechnic are roughly the same as those with a university bachelors degree; over time, university graduates gain a modest margin over polytechnic graduates; in many areas where the polytechnics have specialised in degree teaching - business, computing and engineering - the differences are very slight and in some fields, polytechnic graduates earn more than university graduates on average; and university graduates tend to predominate at the upper ends of the earnings distribution - bachelors graduates with the highest earnings are more likely to have taken their degree at a university.

The causes of the differences in earnings between polytechnic and university graduates are not known for sure. The reasons may include the following: university bachelors students may be better prepared academically for study - either through their school performance or through innate ability; polytechnics may have prepared their graduates better for the workforce, while university graduates reveal their skills more slowly; and in some fields, polytechnic bachelors degrees have been concentrated in occupations that traditionally attract lower salaries.

Published abstract.

  [-] Show less

This report compares the earnings of people who have completed a bachelors degree at a university with the earnings those who completed a similar qualification at a polytechnic. The key finding of the report is that there is no evidence to substantiate claims of labour market discrimination against polytechnic degrees. In particular: there is no discrimination at the point of entry into the labour market - the median earnings of those entering the workforce with a bachelors degree from a polytechnic are roughly the same as those with a university bachelors degree; over time, university ...  [+] Show more

Subjects: Employment; Labour market; Higher education; Outcomes; Providers of education and training; Research; Statistics; Income; Career development; Qualifications

Keywords: University; Outcomes of education and training; Comparative analysis; Polytechnic; Research project; Data analysis; Wage differential; Career choice; Educational level

Geographic subjects: Oceania; New Zealand

Published: [Wellington, New Zealand]: New Zealand Ministry of Education, 2009

Physical description: 15 p.

Access item:
http://www.educationcounts.govt.nz/__data/assets/pdf_file/0010/35992/where-you-study.pdf
Request Item from NCVER

Series:
Beyond tertiary study

ISBN: 9780478139808 (print); 9780478139815 (online)

Statement of responsibility: Roger Smyth ... [et al.]

Resource type: Report

Call Number:
TD/TNC 95.490



NCVER Author-Date style

 
Citation only
Full record
End Note
Plain Text
Rich Text
MS Word
 
 

 

Download